My Comments About Jane Doe, Cornell, and the Thin Line Between "Fine" and Forever Changed




Greetings from Chaton's World in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania! In my world, my days often start with laundry, early-morning emails, and making my kids a hot breakfast. They often end with late-night homework checks, making Instagram reels, and appearing on Celebrity Court of Public Opinion. Somewhere in between, I’m navigating boardrooms, working towards deadlines, and immersed in the good, bad, and ugly chaos of motherhood and household management. As a working mom of three and a professional carving out space in corporate environments, I share my journey of balancing leadership with loving my family, and I sprinkle it with self-care tips. Here, you’ll find honest reflections, hard-earned lessons, and practical strategies for creating an authentic life that you enjoy. If you’re trying to do it all without losing yourself in the process, you have found your sister in the struggle! Continue reading to discover some thoughts, hacks, and/or lessons that I have learned from navigating my world.


What happened to Jane Doe at Cornell is the embodiment of my greatest fears as a former college student.

Not because I got drunk, drugged and raped.

It is not because it her story is my story. The story resonated with me because it could have been my story.

During my first year of college, I attended a Halloween party with a group of friends. At some        point, I looked up and saw them from a distance climbing out of a window to leave for another     party. Suddenly, I was alone.

I was seventeen years old.

I was in a fraternity mansion on fraternity row.

And I was with a fraternity member who was several years older than me, someone I believe was around twenty-two.

We went downstairs to his bedroom, and he closed the door.

Looking back, people can debate every decision that led up to that moment. Had I consented to going downstairs? Yes. Had I willingly entered the room? Yes.

Did I immediately regret the decision?

Absolutely.

What I remember most is not panic. It was paralysis.

The music upstairs was loud. I doubted anyone would hear me if I screamed.

He was much bigger than I was. I wasn't certain I could leave without his permission, and I didn't know whether he would give it.

So I became strategic.

I sat on the bed.

I kissed him.

Not because I desired anything more.

Not because my heart consented.

But because it seemed like the safest path available to me in that moment.

 I learned that behavior and desire are not always aligned. Sometimes behavior can be strategic. 


I wish that more young men knew that absent an enthusiastic, "yes", they really don't know whether the girl wants them or whether she is simply surviving the best way she knows how... 


Back to what happened...

 

My mind kept racing. I knew I had to get out of there and wanted to do it with my virginity intact. 


So... I devised an escape.

I sat upright and did what I did best--talk. I had been voted, "Most Talkative Girl", in my senior class. So, I was kind of an expert at talking and I began doing it incessantly.

 I started talking about my friends. I told him I was worried about them. I said I felt guilty that we had become separated. I told him that I had to call my mother. I told him I had to study for a test. I told him that I was a virgin. I just filled the room up with so much sound that desire had no oxygen on which to thrive. 


Talking saved me and eventually, he agreed that we should go back upstairs, and he walked me back to my dorm.

Nothing happened, really.

I was physically unharmed. 

And for many years, I told myself that was the entire story. I've even told it as a joke.

But Jane Doe's story reminded me that it wasn't funny at all.

I may have been lucky, but in real time, I did not know that I would be. And, the fear I felt in that moment was very real. 

It is not the only time that I altered  my behavior with a man to secure my personal safety.  It became instinctive. And, I know that I am not the only woman who has done that.

When people discuss stories like Jane Doe's, conversations often become exercises in hindsight. Why did she go there? Why did she drink? Why didn't she leave? Why didn't she fight? Why didn't she scream?

Sometimes the screaming occurs in your heart and never makes it to your lips. Fear can be paralyzing and silencing.

Those questions are misplaced. The questions should not focus on her behavior. They should focus on whether she was afraid and how that fear influenced her actions.

We live in a country where women have learned to adjust in response to a myriad of influences. And, fear is closer to the surface of their interactions with men than they'd like to admit. 

Men should understand that fear does not always look like resistance. Sometimes it looks like compliance. Sometimes it looks like calculating risks.

Sometimes it looks like smiling when you want to run. Sometimes, it feels like a kiss.  

When you factor in the size differences and strength differences between men and women, women navigating fear and desire often happens simultaneously and unconsciously. 


I was lucky... I was lucky that he ultimately respected my boundaries. I was lucky that I know how to run my mouth.  I was lucky that my story ended differently...  


However, Jane Doe's story resonates with me because her ending could have been mine or and any other woman’s.

 I am no smarter.

I am no stronger.

Comments